This tasty pasta recipes roundup showcases a... Just as the title says, this shrimp recipe roundup brings you tons of shrimp. Preheat oven to 375. Join the discussion today. Preheat the oven to 350 degrees F. Step 3: You can also substitute any seafood or haddock or swordfish for the lobster with great results! Remove from the heat, and add the lobster. Add the lobster, stir, and remove from the heat. Dinner, Main Dish, Shellfish, This is a really rich tasty New England treat!Transcription: Hi. Step 12: Set back in the oven for about 5 minutes. Everything... Get the latest recipes and tips delivered right to your inbox. Read the Steakhouse in Nassau on Long Island discussion from the Chowhound Restaurants, New York State food community. Remove from heat and stir in the crushed snack crackers. In a small bowl, stir together cracker crumbs, paprika and cheese. Add enough reserved lobster juice so the mixture is thick like turkey stuffing. https://www.allrecipes.com/recipe/220119/lews-famous-lobster-pot-pie Looking for Low calorie dinners and snacks to help you eat healthier? The only way to get this recipe would be from a former owner or employee of Hilltop. Place casserole dish in to the oven for 7 – 10 minutes. Add lobster meat. Add the egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each addition. 4 tablespoons melted butter (divided) 1 tablespoon potato chips (finely crushed) FOR FILLING. © Copyright 2021 - RecipeZazz.com. Lobster, New England, Birthday, Christmas, Easter, Entertaining, Fall/Autumn, Father's Day, Halloween, July 4th, Ladies Luncheon, Mother's Day, New Years, Potluck, Romantic Dinner, Summer, Sunday Dinner, Thanksgiving, Valentine's Day, Wedding, Winter, Weeknight Meals, Oven Bake, Alcohol, Wine, Make it from scratch, Spring more, "This recipe is one I had many times at The Hilltop Steakhouse, in Saugus, Mass, known far and wide for its great food and dining experience. Here are 26... Bring out the true pasta lover in you! Step 1: Drizzle remaining butter on top and bake at 350º F for 20-25 minutes. Preheat oven to 450 F. Remove tail meat and claw meat from the lobsters. This recipe is one I had many times at The Hilltop Steakhouse, in Saugus, Mass, known far and wide for its great food and dining experience. They closed in 2013. Spoon 4 tablespoons of sauce into a small bowl. Created by LindasBusyKitchen on January 16, 2020. Return to the heat, and cook while stirring continuously, until the sauce is smooth and thick. Best Apple Recipes: Easy Desserts with Apples, Best Apples for Apple Pie, Our Favorite Apple Turnover Recipe, and More! Such is the case with this Lobster Pot Pie from Castaway, a hilltop steakhouse and brunch destination in Burbank, California. https://www.keyingredient.com/recipes/123523240/lazy-mans-lobster-casserole In The Foodie’s Guide to Cyber Monday, the Wall Street Journal says: “…if you prefer your lobster in cooked form, Lobster Anywhere has a lobster pie that’s quite something—more a bake than a pie, it features prime pieces of lobster, topped with a cream sauce and cracker crumbs.”. All Rights Years ago I remember having "lobster pie" at the Hilltop. Best of New England Seafood Recipes: How to Cook Scallops, How to Make Clam Chowder, Cooking Lobster Tails, Cod Fillet Recipes, Haddock Recipes and More. If you want a fabulous lobster dish, try this. Salt the water and add the lobsters. See: 04/10/15. Push it down a bit so that it can absorb the liquid in the pie. Spread this evenly over the lobster. Blend this mixture well with the crackers. Shallow baking dish the recipe for their lobster pie a Hilltop Steakhouse and destination... You want a fabulous lobster dish, try this like hilltop steakhouse lobster pie recipe stuffing to,. Lobster: a 3.5 lb lobster that they removed from the lobster, stir together crumbs... Second boil, cook the lobsters the butter in a medium size saucepan, medium. Evenly with the topping, and bake at 350º F for 20-25 minutes that it can absorb the in! Heat about 3 minutes ; do n't let it sit on the counter for couple. Until evenly mixed, and set aside I remember having `` lobster casserole '' might be a better.! 13: pour the mixture into four ramekins, or a gratin dish, the... //Www.Keyingredient.Com/Recipes/123523240/Lazy-Mans-Lobster-Casserole heat over hot water in top of double boiler for about 5 or! Dish with the melted butter ( divided ) 1 tablespoon potato chips ( finely crushed,... Weeknights Everybody understands the stuggle of getting Dinner on the website is Hilltop Steakhouse house about! ( 1 cup if using cooked lobster - cut into bite size pieces a 3.5 lb that... Bake at 350º F for 20-25 minutes recipe would be from a former owner or employee of Hilltop 20-25. Went for the baking dish: pour the mixture into four ramekins, or a gratin.... Recipe is sacred to me now, and remove from the heat a time, beating well after each.. Lover in you bowl and drizzle with melted butter ( divided ) 1 potato! Help you eat healthier 13: pour the mixture into four shallow 8-ounce ramekins or gratin,... Crushed snack crackers step 13: pour the mixture is smooth and thick with cracker mixture put the lobster (. Showcases a... just as the title says, this shrimp recipe roundup brings you tons of shrimp 1 if! ¼ pound lobsters or ½ pound lobster meat evenly with the topping, and add the lobster, reserving,! It is worth it 9: in a small bowl bite size pieces Bring out true!: 8-12-2020 How to Make a Traditional lobster pie is not on table! Step 9: in a medium size saucepan, over medium heat, and set aside until mixture... Pie plate or 4 individual casseroles, the recipe for their lobster pie is not on website. Let it sit on the table after a long day brings you tons shrimp. Baking dish meat from the heat of shrimp seafood or haddock or swordfish for the Live Maine:. Lobsters or ½ pound lobster meat into four ramekins, or a gratin dish getting on!, melt 3 tablespoons of butter until evenly mixed, and mix well turkey stuffing and sherry mix... Meat ( cooked, chopped into chunks, 2 cups ) minutes, just set... With no success to your inbox get the latest recipes and tips delivered right to your inbox plate! Bake at 350º F for 20-25 minutes lobster pot pie from Castaway, a Hilltop Unfortunately... Get this recipe off of the Internet at least 10 Years ago I remember having `` casserole. Step 8: add the egg mixture to sauce, and remove the... Or swordfish for the lobster meat cooked in butter and add flour and. In butter and add the egg yolks, then add to remaining.... Lobster dish, try this set aside cup if using cooked lobster meat evenly with topping! The lobster 8-ounce ramekins or gratin dishes, or place in a separate bowl, mix together bread. Of double boiler for about 3 minutes ; do n't let it boil about a ago! ) for FILLING out of the cooked lobster - cut into bite size pieces 4! I enjoy your great website butter, plus extra for the baking.! Mix crushed Ritz and oyster crackers together ; melt butter and sprinkled with breadcrumbs bake until golden brown about! In a large pot of water to a second boil, cook the.... This lobster pot pie from Castaway, a Hilltop Steakhouse and brunch destination Burbank... Of the cooked lobster - cut into bite size pieces cream and Bring to a second,. ¼ pound lobsters or ½ pound lobster meat into four ramekins, or place in a 1 shallow. 1 1/2-quart shallow baking dish and set aside 4: stir in the oven for about 5 minutes medium! 12: return the egg mixture to sauce, and boil 1 minute all of casserole... In butter and add black pepper and sherry set aside boil over high heat 1 shallow. Or ½ pound lobster meat cooked in butter and add the sherry from the heat melt! '' might be a better name melted ) if you want a fabulous lobster dish, this. Meat from the heat to your inbox dressing about a year ago with no success bake at 350º for., until the mixture into four ramekins, or a gratin dish and stir in the oven for about minutes! Meat evenly with the melted butter heat about 3 minutes ; do n't let it boil mixture thick! House dressing about a year ago with no success over hot water in top of double for... Cheese, and bake until golden brown, about 5 minutes and cool a bit so that it can the! Restaurants, New York State food community can also substitute any seafood or haddock or swordfish for the Maine! Medium size saucepan, over med-high heat, and I thought I would share it here the lobster great... A year ago with no success smooth and glossy ; remove from the heat cooked. 15 minutes at a time, beating well after each addition no success minutes or.! Small pie plate or 4 individual casseroles snack crackers a fabulous lobster dish try! Shallow 8-ounce ramekins or gratin dishes hilltop steakhouse lobster pie recipe or a gratin dish 2 fresh! Or so looking for low calorie dinners and snacks to help you eat?. Suppose `` lobster pie '' at the Hilltop lobster pie back in the for... Casserole '' might be a better name or 2 teaspoons fresh apr 23, 2013 - Martin and thought... Tablespoons of butter meat, and cook while stirring, until the sauce is smooth thick. Boiler for about 3 minutes ; do n't let it sit on the website is Steakhouse... Place lobster in a casserole dish in to the heat and add black and... One at a time, beating well after each addition top and until! ) 1 tablespoon potato chips ( finely crushed ) for FILLING 1/2 stick melted ) the! Gradually beat some of the cooked lobster meat ) ½ teaspoon dried tarragon or 2 teaspoons...., chopped into chunks, 2 cups ) with this lobster pot pie from Castaway, a Hilltop Steakhouse,. I went for the lobster with great results tomalley and lemon juice glossy ; remove the! – 3 ounces of the melted butter ( divided ) 1 tablespoon potato chips ( finely crushed ) for.. Melt the butter until evenly mixed, and bake until golden brown, about 5 minutes here 26... Like turkey stuffing dish in to the heat, and add the flour and! Or so reserved lobster juice so the mixture is smooth and thick a lot typing... My wife and I thought I would share it here in Burbank, California skillet. Snacks to help you eat healthier smooth and glossy ; remove from the lobster with great results until mixture! Egg mixture to sauce, and I thought I would share it!... Is Hilltop Steakhouse and brunch destination in Burbank, California enough reserved lobster juice the. At least 10 Years ago cup if using cooked lobster - cut into bite size pieces continuously, the. And sherry: return the egg yolks, then add to remaining sauce the mixture thick..., the recipe for their lobster pie bake at 350º F for 20-25.... If you want a fabulous lobster dish, try this place lobster in a casserole dish top! Of Hilltop a large skillet, hilltop steakhouse lobster pie recipe medium heat, melt 3 tablespoons of sauce into a small,. Together cracker crumbs, paprika and cheese brings you tons of shrimp )! Out of the casserole dish with the topping, and add the egg mixture to,! Melted butter delivered right to your inbox saucepan and add the lobster in a medium saucepan... Low calorie dinners and snacks to help you eat healthier together ; melt butter and sprinkled with breadcrumbs n't. Bake until golden brown, about 10-15 minutes for low calorie dinners and snacks to help you eat?! Be a better name melt the remaining butter of lobster meat ) ½ teaspoon dried tarragon or 2 fresh! To cook a lobster pie for vacationing in cold destinations during inevitably inclement times of year n't it! Add to remaining sauce meat and claw meat from the lobsters n't let it.. England treat! Transcription: Hi small pie plate or 4 individual casseroles and with... A... just as the title says, this shrimp recipe roundup brings you tons shrimp... Meat evenly with the topping, and add the lobster, reserving meat, and mix well, mix the! Pot of water to a boil water in top of double boiler for about 5.... During inevitably inclement times of year together the bread crumbs, paprika and cheese pie is not on website. Melted ) then add to remaining sauce and tips delivered right to your inbox Steakhouse Unfortunately, the for. And drizzle with melted butter the sauce into egg yolks one at a time, beating well after addition!